THE COLLEGIAN
  • Home
  • News
  • Entertainment
    • Gael Giggles
  • Perspectives & Opinion
    • Gael Gossip
    • Ask a Gael
    • Horoscopes
  • Sports
  • About
    • From the Editor
    • Meet the Team
    • Archived
    • Editor letters Archive
    • Past Staff
    • Legal Statement

Perspectives & opinion

Israel, Palestine, and the Future in Trump’s Hands

5/14/2025

1 Comment

 
By Salahideen Salem
Opinion Columnist

A conflict often discussed around the world today ended up surfacing in discussion within St. Mary’s in the form of the Israeli/Palestinian conflict. A controversial subject, this has remained a contentious matter over the past year, and it has so far been addressed by the college. With more knowledge surfacing through the media, a current of awareness has emerged throughout many places in America, including St. Mary’s, that Israel is conducting a genocide on the Palestinian people, as shown by Amnesty International’s and the UN’s writings on how long the conflict has been going on for. As a Palestinian and someone who has kept a close eye on colonial movements throughout history, this subject means a lot to me. Every day, I see the deaths, be they old or young, prosperous or not, with hopes and dreams crushed, and honestly I wish to speak out about this now. With what I will address next, I think it is most important to do so now.

Time has drawn on and the conflict has partially faded in people’s minds as election year has taken prominence in the American landscape. The question has turned from “how can we help stop this genocide” to “what will happen now in Trump’s hands” In this, the answer to many Americans has been clear, with his ineptitude carrying the day often with his actions. One example would be in his desire to make Gaza the 51st state of the United States. In the current landscape of America, we have faced great sums of money diverted from institutions such as healthcare and aid to the poor to now genocide, and ultimately we must ask ourselves how this problem will be solved. The answer, however, seems clear to many amidst the burgeoning ethical and economic issues that plague the world today. They will not be solved, at least, not by Trump, especially not with his current policies. His foreign policy especially seems to be no different from Biden’s, outright stating “Do what you have to do.” to Benjamin Netanyahu during the election. Furthermore, with the burgeoning economic crisis on the rise and the recession that has been ignored due to the elections, it appears that Trump has elected to cause new problems instead of fixing any. He’s cracking down on colleges now, after all . 

Despite all of this it is not a reason to lose hope. Simply because the person before President Biden is at the wheel again does not mean that it is cause to lose hope. Four years is a relative eyeblink in the passage of time, and we still have to focus and keep fighting. The world will change, but that does not mean we should not stop fighting injustice.

With Trump doubling down on America’s already abysmal foreign policies, we must endeavor to keep on speaking, not only for us as Americans but also as people. Just because everyday life continues does not mean we should not hold ourselves accountable. Just because we are local in Moraga does not mean that we can keep silent. Every act of speaking out begins small, and ultimately, this is no different. Time is moving fast and we have to act with it. The only question is how we shall do so.
    
And the answer to that, I feel, is obvious. Though politicians will pretend not to hear, we must raise our voices. We have to grasp the truth and hold it high. There is no other means of going about it beyond non-violence. Speak up. Shout louder. Protest, even. It will all make a difference, no matter how small it might seem.

 Amnesty International. “Israel Defying ICJ Ruling to Prevent Genocide by Failing to Allow Aid into Gaza.” Amnesty International, 26 Feb. 2024, www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2024/02/israel-defying-icj-ruling-to-prevent-genocide-by-failing-to-allow-adequate-humanitarian-aid-to-reach-gaza/. 
​




1 Comment
RA Slater
10/20/2026 01:18:19 am

Hello, I am Palestinian.

And since honesty is so rare in my politics, let me confess a few things.

1947.
The UN offered me a state.
Alongside Israel.
Borders, independence, recognition.
I said no.
My leaders promised that war would "drive the Jews into the sea."
Instead, I lost everything and they called it a catastrophe.
Not because they didn't offer me a state, but because I rejected it.

1948–2025.
Arab states could have integrated me, given me rights, passports, dignity.
Instead, they locked me in refugee camps for generations, so I would remain a weapon against Israel.
They built palaces for themselves and prisons for me.
They used me as propaganda, not as people.

1967.
After another lost war, I could have built a state in the West Bank and Gaza.
Instead, I insisted on "no peace, no recognition, no negotiations."
Three noes.
Fifty years later,
I still have no state.
Turns out, rejection doesn't pay the rent.

Oslo,
1990s.
Israel said: "Let's try it."
It gave me autonomy.
Weapons for the police.
Billions in aid.
What did my leaders do?
They stole the money, armed militias, and launched an intifada.
Suicide bombings instead of schools.
Rockets instead of factories.

Gaza, 2005.
Israel left completely.
No settlers, no soldiers.
I had the chance to turn Gaza into a Mediterranean Singapore.
I voted for Hamas.
They turned it into Mogadishu by the sea.
Billions in aid?
Tunnels, rockets, and palaces for their leaders, while my people eat canned food in the dark.

Democracy?
I haven't had elections in nearly 20 years.
Hamas kills dissenters in Gaza.
Fatah imprisons them in the West Bank.
My leaders cancel elections because they're too busy fighting for power.

Religion. Instead of building a future,
I put clerics on TV teaching children to hate Jews.
I glorify "martyrs" who blow up buses.
I raise my children with songs of blood and fire instead of books and science.
I trade hope for holy war.

Arab world.
Arab regimes call me "brother."
But ask them how many Palestinians can live freely in Lebanon, Syria, Egypt, or Kuwait.
They exclude me, but celebrate my death, because my death is their excuse.

Absurdity.
I keep saying I want to "build a state."
And ironically, right next door is Israel: the neighbor that built a thriving democracy, a tech powerhouse, farms in the desert, cities from dust. No oil, no infinite wealth, just courage.
I could have learned, copied, collaborated.
Instead, I chose envy and rage.

Anti-Jewish obsession. I could have accepted Jews as neighbors.
I could have said: "Two nations, two states." Instead, I repeat: "From the river to the sea."
Instead of displaying honor, hospitality, and rich Arab culture, I showed only the culture of the sword: anger, extremism, and blood.
Instead of shouting salaam (peace) to Israelis, I shouted death to the Jews.
And then I pretend to be surprised when Israelis don't trust me, when they're angry, disappointed, and convinced I don't want coexistence at all.

Responsibility.
I blame Israel for everything.
Always.
My leaders steal billions?
Israel's fault.
Hamas fires rockets from hospitals?
Israel's fault.
I glorify death over life?
Israel's fault.
Responsibility isn't my strong suit.

I am Palestinian.
I could have built a nation, many times.
I chose rejection, corruption, and endless war.
I could have lived in peace with Israel, but I chose to live in the shadow of its destruction.

So yes, I am a victim.
But too often, I am a victim of my own leaders, my own choices, and my own refusal to let go of hate.

And that, dear reader, is the tragedy no one wants to admit.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    STAFF

    Norah Schramm '26, MA '27
    Editor-in-Chief​

    ​Salahideen Salem '27
    Perspectives & Opinion Editor

    Archives

    October 2026
    May 2025
    November 2024
    October 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    December 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    November 2022
    May 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

Interested? We Would Love to have you join our staff, or pitch us a story!


contact us:

[email protected]
​[email protected]
  • Home
  • News
  • Entertainment
    • Gael Giggles
  • Perspectives & Opinion
    • Gael Gossip
    • Ask a Gael
    • Horoscopes
  • Sports
  • About
    • From the Editor
    • Meet the Team
    • Archived
    • Editor letters Archive
    • Past Staff
    • Legal Statement